Byrnes: This proposed change introduces a brand new complexity into the tax code that we simply don’t want. I’m not saying we don’t need to encourage retirement saving. In fact, we need to provide tax incentives to permit People to make amends for funding retirement accounts. My challenge with this proposal is that it supplies totally different pretax contribution limits for 5 totally different age teams — which makes little or no sense and appears fully arbitrary.
Bloink: We’re speaking about offering an added retirement financial savings possibility for People who might have lastly completed paying off mortgages, pupil loans, their youngsters’s schooling, and different important debt — and now they’re lastly capable of dedicate a better proportion of their earnings towards retirement financial savings within the years instantly previous to retirement.
Byrnes: Permitting anybody 50 and as much as profit from the highest-value catch-up restrict can be a way more environment friendly means of encouraging saving. We must be targeted on fostering simplicity within the tax code in order that unusual People really perceive the principles and the advantages obtainable to them. That means, they’ve the instruments to judge their private monetary scenario and profit from the tax-preferred financial savings choices on the market.
Bloink: With the instability we’ve seen this previous yr, now is an ideal time to encourage saving to advertise safety amongst older People. As a result of the added contributions can be handled as Roth contributions, the federal government wouldn’t be shedding any income by providing the extra retirement financial savings possibility. I don’t see any drawback with this kind of financial savings incentive.
Byrnes: Altering the principles just for taxpayers who’ve reached three totally different ages is mindless to me. Why not apply the change to any taxpayer who’s eligible to make catch-up contributions? As a result of the added contributions are handled as Roths, there’s no monetary purpose for members of Congress to single out three totally different age teams and apply totally different guidelines. We must always merely up the ante on catch-up contributions for all taxpayers who’ve reached age 50.