Thursday, December 8, 2022
HomeBankDistant working, bargaining energy and productiveness – Financial institution Underground

Distant working, bargaining energy and productiveness – Financial institution Underground

Lena Anayi

Distant working soared in the course of the Covid-19 (Covid) pandemic. Over half of British staff labored from dwelling in the course of the preliminary Covid lockdowns (first panel in Chart 1). And by February this yr, practically a 3rd of staff had been nonetheless doing so not less than a number of the time. However will this final? On this weblog submit, I discover companies’ and staff’ attitudes to distant working, the extent to which these could differ, and components which may have an effect on negotiations between them on future distant working preparations.

Chart 1: Proportion of staff working from dwelling, full-time or hybrid(a)(b)

Sources: BBC/YouGov, Choice Maker Panel (DMP), Labour Pressure Survey, ONS Enterprise Insights and Circumstances Survey (BICS), ONS Opinion and Way of life Survey, Prolific, and Understanding Society.

(a) BICS outcomes relate to staff solely, and DMP outcomes relate to full-time staff solely.
(b) The second panel presents the vary of outcomes (minimal and most) inside every class.

In fact, because the Covid pandemic continues, many staff and companies will nonetheless be determining their long-term distant working preferences. And lack of matched worker-firm knowledge containing data on each units of preferences means researchers could wrestle to precisely estimate the diploma to which particular person staff’ preferences are misaligned with these of their employers.

Misalignment in staff’ and companies’ preferences round distant working

Nonetheless, varied survey outcomes present that future distant working preferences differ throughout staff and companies. The second panel in Chart 1 exhibits that, post-pandemic, staff want extra distant working than they anticipate shall be accessible to them, and their expectations are barely larger than these of companies. Many staff could due to this fact want extra distant working post-pandemic than their particular person employers shall be keen to accommodate.

It might even be attainable to gauge a point of misaligned preferences by investigating the drivers of those. As an example, what if staff and companies had been all motivated by the identical factor, equivalent to maximising productiveness? In that case, assuming mutual settlement on how distant working impacts this, there will not be a lot disagreement round future preparations in spite of everything.

Beginning with the drivers of staff’ preferences, I run a probit regression utilizing the Understanding Society family survey micro-data, with a dependent dummy variable for whether or not the employee wishes extra distant working post-pandemic relative to pre-pandemic. As explanatory variables, I embody employee demographics equivalent to gender, age, stage of schooling, area, family measurement and whether or not they’re a mother or father of dependent kids. I embody employer trade (A38 group), agency measurement and the agency’s versatile working coverage. I additionally embody job-related traits equivalent to mode of employment (worker versus self-employed), pre-Covid earnings, weekly hours labored throughout Covid (complete, extra time hours, and alter relative to pre-Covid), workplace commuting time, job tenure, occupation (NS-SEC group), and whether or not the person is a ‘key employee‘, in addition to distant working standing pre and through Covid. And I embody staff’ subjective assessments across the impression of distant engaged on their hourly productiveness throughout Covid, pre-Covid work-life steadiness, pre-Covid job satisfaction, and whether or not they skilled emotions of loneliness throughout Covid.

The regression outcomes (with statistically vital regressors proven in Chart 2) reveal a number of issues.

First, staff’ distant working preferences are unrelated to employer traits, except for their versatile working coverage. This means that staff’ preferences can’t be predicted primarily based on their employers’ traits, implying that staff and companies could typically disagree.

Second, preferences are additionally unrelated to employee demographic traits.

Third, employee preferences are positively related to whether or not the employee had been working from dwelling throughout Covid (with this making them 19% extra more likely to favour extra of it post-pandemic, all else equal), and whether or not they discovered it to be productivity-enhancing (with every 10 proportion level increase to productiveness making them 4% extra probably). Greater each day commuting time to the workplace additionally raises staff’ propensity to favour extra distant working (with every further hour making staff 4% extra probably), as does dissatisfaction with work-life steadiness (8% extra probably) and basic job dissatisfaction (8% extra probably). In the meantime, emotions of loneliness throughout Covid decrease staff’ propensity to favour extra distant working post-pandemic (18% much less probably), as does being a ‘key employee’ (16% much less probably).

Maybe surprisingly, staff that had already been working remotely pre-pandemic are much less more likely to favour extra of it post-pandemic, suggesting a attainable restrict to how a lot distant working staff finally want.

Chart 2: Drivers of employee preferences round elevated distant working post-pandemic(a)(b)

Supply: Understanding Society.

(a) Common marginal results are reported because of the non-linearity of the probit hyperlink operate, such that the estimated impression of any regressor varies as its amount will increase.
(b) N = 1,979. MacFadden R-squared = 0.27. Log-likelihood = -879.51.

Turning to the drivers of companies’ preferences, I run the same probit regression utilizing the BICS firm-level knowledge. As explanatory variables, I embody agency demographics equivalent to agency age, measurement, area, trade (A38 group) and possession origin (UK/EU/US), and I additionally embody pre-Covid data on (log) productiveness, stage of intangible property, and ratio of workplace rental prices to revenues. These data are drawn from companies’ pre-Covid responses to the Annual Enterprise Survey (ABS). Moreover, I embody data on whether or not companies raised distant working ranges throughout Covid, peak distant working throughout Covid (proportion of staff), and their subjective evaluation of how distant working impacts productiveness (which I interpret as referring to employee effectivity).

The regression outcomes (with statistically vital regressors proven in Chart 3) point out that companies discovering distant working to be productiveness enhancing are 44% extra more likely to favour extra of it post-pandemic (versus these discovering it to be productiveness impartial), all else equal, whereas these discovering it productiveness decreasing are 28% much less probably to take action.

Nevertheless, productiveness isn’t the one consideration for companies. These with larger office-related overhead prices additionally want extra distant working post-pandemic, with every further proportion level improve within the ratio of overhead prices to revenues making a agency 4% extra probably to take action. These companies could want price financial savings by reductions in workplace hire, and as renters they might even have extra flexibility to make such changes. Value reductions may also contribute in the direction of improved agency productiveness by larger revenue margins.

Curiously, US-owned companies are 14% much less more likely to favour extra distant working post-pandemic (versus UK owned), suggesting that cultural components is also at play.

Chart 3: Drivers of employer preferences round elevated distant working post-pandemic(a)(b)

Supply: BICS knowledge matched with ABS.

(a) Common marginal results are reported because of the non-linearity of the probit hyperlink operate, such that the estimated impression of any regressor varies as its amount will increase.
(b) N = 2,659. MacFadden R-squared = 0.48. Log-likelihood = -5691.55.

For each staff and companies, due to this fact, productiveness concerns are vital. However there are different vital components too, a few of which companies and staff could overlook. Employees could want work-life steadiness, office camaraderie or shorter commutes, whereas companies could want price financial savings arising by decrease workplace rents.

Negotiations between staff and employers: a bargaining energy story?

Competing preferences between staff and companies could create alternatives for negotiation, if employers comply with this. BICS survey respondents had been requested in September 2021 about their ‘most important consideration when deciding who can return to their regular workplace’. Chart 4 exhibits that round half of companies (52%) indicated a willingness to barter with staff, with round a 3rd (32%) unwilling to take action. Throughout that very same interval, companies who had been keen to barter over working preparations had double the proportion of staff working remotely (26% versus 13%).

Chart 4: Whether or not the employer or worker determines future working preparations

Supply: BICS (wave 39).

Though the survey query asks particularly in regards to the timing of staff’ return to workplaces, companies’ decision-making round this can be assumed to correlate intently with their broader distant working preparations for the long run.

Are companies which can be keen to barter merely extra conscious of worker preferences? Or maybe they’ve comparatively weak bargaining energy? Possibly they’re higher capable of accommodate worker preferences, attributable to being extra worthwhile?

There are numerous measures of each employer bargaining energy and agency profitability that enable us to check a few of these prospects. I run one other probit regression utilizing the BICS firm-level knowledge (once more matched with pre-Covid ABS responses), this time with propensity to barter because the binary consequence of curiosity. Controlling for agency measurement, productiveness and trade, I concurrently embody varied indicators of weaker agency bargaining energy as explanatory variables, every of that are individually positively related to propensity to barter. These embody unionisation at office, reliance on migrant labour, whether or not the agency is at present struggling to rent, going through labour shortages or excessive workers turnover, or has just lately raised staff’ wages, and firm-level labour tightness (ratio of vacancies to employment). I additionally embody revenue margins (pre-Covid) and reported Covid impression on earnings as profitability metrics, each of that are individually positively related to propensity to barter. And I embody companies’ reported distant working productiveness impacts, and overhead prices relative to revenues.

I discover that reported productiveness impacts of distant working finest explains companies’ willingness to barter. Neither bargaining energy nor profitability measures matter when all components are thought-about concurrently. Employers are 14% extra more likely to negotiate in the event that they deem distant working to be productivity-enhancing (relative to discovering it productivity-neutral). This can be as a result of they understand fewer productiveness dangers round probably permitting staff to go for continued distant working. In flip, employers are 21% much less more likely to negotiate in the event that they discover it to be productivity-diminishing.


Elevated distant working is more likely to stay a everlasting characteristic of the post-pandemic British financial system. However the extent of this may depend upon each companies’ and staff’ preferences, and these will not be aligned. Corporations could favour decrease overhead prices, whereas staff could search higher work-life steadiness or shorter commutes. And even when they each search to advertise productiveness, they might disagree over the impression of distant engaged on this, as an illustration if staff fail to internalise its results on group cohesion or concepts era, or if companies ignore its impression on employee engagement. When staff’ and companies’ preferences differ, an employer’s willingness to barter with its staff is more likely to rely largely by itself evaluation of the productiveness impacts of distant working.

Lena Anayi works within the Financial institution’s Structural Economics Division.

If you wish to get in contact, please e mail us at or depart a remark beneath.

Feedback will solely seem as soon as accredited by a moderator, and are solely printed the place a full identify is provided. Financial institution Underground is a weblog for Financial institution of England workers to share views that problem – or help – prevailing coverage orthodoxies. The views expressed listed below are these of the authors, and are usually not essentially these of the Financial institution of England, or its coverage committees.


Most Popular

Recent Comments